The Ultimate Guide to Cigar Cutters

Posted by James Wiedenbeck on

guide to cigar cutters

So much about your cigar experience will depend on your cut. It’s where you start your smoking ritual, so you want to make sure the cut you’re getting sets you up for a great experience. Trying use a low-grade cutter can leave you with a mess on your hands. You need something quality to make sure you’re getting the most out of your cigars and there’s more than one way to do that. Below we highlight the array of different cutters, varying in style and purpose.


Straight cut guillotine cutters are one of the most popular cutters you’ll find on the market, and with good reason. A guillotine cutter, especially a double blade version, all but guarantees a clean cut every time you use it simply by cutting the cigar from both sides simultaneously. In one fell swoop, you easily can cut the cap off of your stogie. The Xikar XO Double Guillotine Cutter is a great example of a cutter that guides you to the perfect cut. Being spring loaded, you won’t have to put too much effort into it either.


Not all cuts actually require you to remove the whole cap. A punch cut (or bullet punch) works by cutting a small hole at the top of the cap, leaving most of the cigar intact. You’ll also find less tobacco flakes in your mouth than you would with other cuts. Punch-cuts are a matter of preference, with some smokers feeling like the small hole makes it a bit tighter to pull from. But one thing’s for sure – these cutters have style. Centerfire Creation’s Bullet Cigar Punch is designed out of a 308 Winchester brass cases and cleans itself automatically. It makes for a sleek and clean “cut” and, well, it just looks so cool.


Another benefit of not cutting off the whole cap is getting more flavor of the cigar. If the tightness of the punch-cut isn’t to your liking, a v-cut may be just what you’re looking for. While v-cutters may look similar to guillotine cutters, they don’t function entirely the same way. Instead of removing the cap or punching a whole, the v-cutter takes out a wedge from the cap of your cigar. It allows you the retain more flavor and breadth of the cigar without having to struggle to pull it out. You shouldn’t buy any cheap cutter if you’re serious about your cigars, but you should especially not buy a cheap v-cutter. Poorly designed v-cutters can cut too deep and ruin all the benefits you should be getting from this style of cut. Instead, spring for something like the Colibri V-cut which will give you a smooth cut and allow you to reap all the benefits a v-cut can provide.


Let’s be clear here – don’t just go and grab a knife from your kitchen or pull out your pocket knife to cut your cigar. If you do, you’re basically guaranteeing that you’re going to damage the cigar and end up with a massive mess on your hands. However, it can be handy to have a cigar knife handy when you’re on the go. The difference between a regular knife and a cigar knife is all in how it’s constructed. Take a look at the Xikar 744 cigar knife. See how the handle has a circular hole in the middle of it? This is where you’ll place the cap of your cigar, then you push down on it from the knife. It’s a great tool to have in a pinch and a whole different animal than using a steak knife on a cutting board (seriously, please don’t do this).

Ready to upgrade your cutter to one of these mentioned above? Check our inventory of cigar cutters and find the one you think might be right for you.

Share this post

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published.

map map map map map

Best Cigar Values

8212 Transit Rd
Williamsville, New york, US

Verified 05/10/2017

SSL Certificate

Best Cigar Values uses a 256-bit SSL certificate to establish a secure encrypted connection between your computer and their servers. This connections protects your sensitive data. All pages, content, credit card,and transaction information is protected by the same level of security used by banks.
Learn more about SSL

Money Back
Verified 05/10/2017

Satisfaction Guareanteed

If you would like to return merchandise, the merchandise must have been purchased within the last 30 days AND you must obtain an RMA# (Return Merchandise Authorization) from You may do so in one of two ways:

1. You may email us at You MUST include your order number, the item you are returning, and the reason you are returning the merchandise.

2. You may call Customer Service at 716-689-2914 Monday through Friday 8:00AM to 5:00PM EST and speak to a Customer Service Representative.

Notice: No returns will be accepted without prior authorization.

Once you have obtained a RMA#, please follow these simple guidelines to return your cigars:

IMPORTANT! Please DO NOT return any cut or partially smoked cigars. Cigars believed to be unsmokable or defective must still be in a condition to be sent back to the manufacturer. If returns are received in less than adequate condition, our Returns Department reserves the right to refuse the package and/or deny or pro-rate your credit accordingly.

Please pack the cigars securely in a clean, odor-free carton suitable for shipping.
Enclose your original invoice in the carton, if possible.
Prominently display the RMA# on the OUTSIDE of the package and address the package to:
8212 Transit Road
Williamsville, NY 14221
Attention: Returns

Verified 05/10/2017

Secure Infrastructure

Best Cigar Values is hosted by Shopify Inc. (NYSE:SHOP) Backed by the leading ecommerce platform enables them to offer 99.99% uptime and 24/7 monitoring.With a large network of servers placed across the world, they can offer you a secure,robust,and performant ecommerce experience.
Learn how to start your own shopify store

Valid 3/25/15 - 3/30/18
Verified 05/10/2017

PCI Complaince

Best Cigar Values is certified Level 1 PCI DSS compliant, the hightest level of security certification. This certification signifies their compliance with standards for security policies,technologies and ongoing processes that protect their payment systems from breaches and theft of cardholder data.
Learn more about PCI.